My older sister is an English major. Is it a problem if she writes my Common App essay from my story?
She's a junior at a good school and a way better writer than me. The plan would be I tell her the story and she writes it. It's still my story, so is that even cheating?
- ?
Yes, that crosses the line, even though the story is yours.
When you submit the Common App you certify that the work is your own. The essay is the one place a reader hears you in your own words, so someone else writing the sentences is exactly what that certification is about. It is treated as misrepresentation, and offers have been rescinded over it.
It also tends to backfire on its own terms. A polished essay that sounds like a college English major sits next to your supplements, your short answers and sometimes a graded writing sample. Readers notice when the voices do not match.
What your sister can legitimately do, and it is a lot:
1. Interview you. Ask "why did that matter?" five times and take notes. Most good essays start in a conversation like that.
2. Read your drafts and tell you where she got bored or confused.
3. Point out clichés and places where you are summarizing instead of showing a moment.Then you rewrite. Feedback is fine. Ghostwriting is not.
A useful test: if you could not explain why every sentence is there, it is not yours yet.