My son refuses to work on his college essays and I don't know how hard to push
I'm a parent posting because I don't know where else to ask without it getting back to people we know.
My son is a senior. He's a good kid with a strong record: 3.9, good scores, captain of his robotics team, works on weekends. Applications are due in a few weeks for early action and he has not written a single word of his essays. Not a draft, not a list of ideas, nothing.
Every time I bring it up he shuts down. He says he'll do it, then goes to his room and plays video games. Last week I made a schedule and taped it to the fridge and he just walked past it. When I tried to sit down with him on Sunday it turned into a shouting match and he said I care more about where he goes than about him. That hurt, and honestly I'm not sure he's wrong.
His father thinks I should back off completely and let him face the consequences. I think if I back off he'll miss every deadline and end up somewhere he doesn't want to be, or nowhere. We've talked about hiring someone but he says he doesn't want a "college coach."
I should also say he is not a bad writer. His English teacher told us at conferences that he writes well when he cares about the topic. So I don't think it's ability. I think he's scared, or he just doesn't want to think about leaving home, which I understand because I don't want to think about that either.
What do I do? Push harder? Back off? Pay someone? I've lost sleep over this for weeks.
TL;DR: senior son with a strong record hasn't started essays, shuts down when I bring it up, deadlines in weeks, I don't know how much to push.
- ?
This is one of the most common situations in senior fall, and the shutting down is usually not laziness. For a lot of students, the essay is the first time they are asked to write about themselves for strangers who decide their future. Avoidance is often fear that the essay will not be good enough.
Some things that tend to help:
1. **Separate the conversation from the work.** One calm talk where you say you trust him, ask what feels hardest, and agree on how you will check in (for example, one short check-in a week, at a time he picks). Then stick to it.
2. **Shrink the first step.** "Write your essay" is too big. "Talk for 15 minutes about three moments you might write about" is doable. Some students find it easier to talk into a voice memo first.
3. **Move the deadline pressure off you.** Ask his school counselor to meet him. A counselor or teacher setting dates often lands better than a parent.
4. **Narrow the early list if needed.** If EA deadlines are close, it may be better to submit two strong early applications than five rushed ones. Regular deadlines are still ahead.
5. **If you hire help, let him choose.** Outside help can work well when the student picks the person and the role is a coach for his own writing, not someone who takes over. If he refuses, a trusted teacher or older cousin reading drafts can do some of the same.His comment that you care more about where he goes than about him is worth answering directly, once: tell him that is not true and that you will be fine wherever he lands. Many students relax and start writing after they hear that.
The Common App essay can be reused for most schools. Once the first one exists, the rest goes faster. Getting one rough draft done is the whole goal for the next week.
Also make sure he knows that deadlines are not all November 1. Show him the real calendar for each school. It often turns one big panic into a few small tasks.